Level E · Fluent

The language and the dialects

Auntie Wang's grandson no longer understands a word of his grandmother's speech. She wonders whether to go on using it with him.

What you learn to do

  • noting a loss between generations
  • shifting a badly put question
  • disputing a superficial remedy
  • deciding to change a habit
  1. Auntie Wang

    孙子现在家乡话

    Wǒ sūnzi xiànzài yī jù jiāxiānghuà dōu bù huì shuō le.

    My grandson can no longer say a single sentence in our home speech.

  2. Xiaoyu

    学校普通话爸妈普通话

    Zài xuéxiào jiǎng pǔtōnghuà, huí jiā bàmā yě jiǎng pǔtōnghuà.

    At school they speak Mandarin, and at home his parents speak Mandarin too.

  3. Auntie Wang

    方言外语

    Wǒ gēn tā shuō fāngyán, tā dèng zhe yǎn kàn wǒ, xiàng zài tīng wàiyǔ.

    When I speak dialect to him he stares at me wide-eyed, as though he were hearing a foreign language.

  4. Chen Hao

    差不多就是开口普通话

    Wǒ yě chàbuduō. Tīng shì néng tīng dǒng, jiùshì Zhāng bù kāi zuǐ. Yī kāikǒu jiù chuàn chéng pǔtōnghuà le.

    It is much the same with me. I can follow when it is spoken, I just cannot open my mouth. The moment I start, it slips into Mandarin.

  5. Zhang laoshi

    你们

    Zhè shì liǎng dài rén de shì. Nǐmen zhè yī dài hái tīng de dǒng, xià yī dài lián tīng dōu bù huì le.

    It plays out over two generations. Yours can still understand; the next will not even be able to follow.

  6. Xiaoyu

    可是普通话不然怎么

    Kěshì pǔtōnghuà zǒng de huì ba ? Bùrán chū le shěng zěnme bàn.

    But you have to know Mandarin, surely? Otherwise how do you manage outside your province?

  7. Zhang laoshi

    当然问题不是普通话

    Dāngrán yào huì. Wèntí bùshì xué pǔtōnghuà, shì bǎ lìng yī zhǒng diū le.

    Of course you must know it. The question is not learning Mandarin, it is losing the other language along the way.

  8. Chen Hao

    现在不是网上方言字幕

    Xiànzài bùshì yǒu rén zài wǎngshàng jiāo fāngyán ma ? Hái yǒu pèi zìmù de.

    Are there not people teaching dialects online now? Some of them even put subtitles on.

  9. Auntie Wang

    俏皮话天天

    Jiāo de shì jǐ jù qiàopihuà, xiào wán jiù wán le. Zhēn yào huì shuō, de tiāntiān yòng.

    What they teach is three set jokes; you laugh and that is that. To really speak it, you have to use it every day.

  10. Zhang laoshi

    阿姨语言不是饭桌

    Āyí shuō dào gēn shàng le. Yǔyán kào de bùshì kè, shì fànzhuō.

    Auntie has got to the root of it. A language is not kept alive by lessons, it is kept alive at the dinner table.

  11. Xiaoyu

    今天孙子说话

    Nà cóng jīntiān qǐ, nín gēn sūnzi shuōhuà jiù bié huàn le.

    Then from today on, do not switch languages when you talk to your grandson.

  12. Auntie Wang

    着急小孩子起来

    Wǒ pà tā tīng bù dǒng, zháojí. Xiǎoháizi jí qilai shì huì kū de.

    I am afraid he will not understand and will get upset. A child who gets upset ends up crying.

  13. Chen Hao

    小孩子我们厉害自然

    Xiǎoháizi bǐ wǒmen xiǎng de lìhai. Tīng shàng bàn nián, zìrán jiù dǒng le.

    Children are better at it than we think. Six months of hearing it and he will understand on his own.

  14. Zhang laoshi

    而且孩子脑子研究

    Érqiě huì liǎng zhǒng huà de háizi, nǎozi zhuǎn de kuài, zhè shì yǒu yánjiū de.

    And children who speak two languages have quicker minds, there is research on it.

  15. Auntie Wang

    反正辈子不能改口

    Nà wǒ shì shì. Fǎnzhèng wǒ shuō le yī bèizi, zǒng bùnéng dào lǎo gǎikǒu.

    Then I will try. I have spoken it all my life, after all; I can hardly change my speech in my old age.

Vocabulary to remember

  • 孙子 sūnzi grandson
  • 家乡话 jiāxiānghuà the speech of one's native place
  • 普通话 pǔtōnghuà Mandarin, standard Chinese
  • 方言 fāngyán dialect
  • 外语 wàiyǔ foreign language
  • 俏皮话 qiàopihuà a quip, a set joke
  • 语言 yǔyán language
  • 饭桌 fànzhuō dining table
  • 着急 zháojí to worry, to be anxious
  • 厉害 lìhai formidable, severe
  • 研究 yánjiū to study, to look into
  • 反正 fǎnzhèng anyway, in any case
  • 改口 gǎikǒu to change what one says, to backtrack

Language points

张不开嘴

Not to manage to open your mouth. The potential complement describes here a block in front of a language you understand without daring to speak it, which is exactly the state of the second generation of internal migrants. The same form serves for a request you cannot bring yourself to make: 这话我张不开嘴.

连…都…

下一代连听都不会了: the next generation will not even be able to follow. The construction 连 + item + 都 puts the stress on an extreme case, the one you would not have thought affected. It always assumes an implicit gradation: if they cannot even understand, it goes without saying they cannot speak.

改口

To change what you say: either to correct yourself after speaking, or to take up another language, another name, another price. Auntie Wang plays on both senses, since it is a matter of her language and of her age at once. The word is common in negotiations, where 改口 means going back on a figure already named.

Share this page